When comparing the essays; 'Beyond
the Glass: The Challenge of Flight
Attendant Rosters' by Jane Citizen (Essay A) and 'The Challenges of the Airline Industry' by John Doe (Essay B) there were a few factors that made Essay A considerably better than Essay B.
- Reference List and In-Text Citation
- Formal Report Structure
In regards to the structure of the report,
Essay A did significantly better than Essay B. It has an Executive Summary as
well as good content organisation and a Conclusion. As Essay B has no structure, the report is
quite difficult to read.
- Effective Writing Style
Effective writing style consists
of;
>
Using active voice and consistent tense
>
Avoiding the use of first person pronouns
>
Using transition words to link sentences
>
Using a variety of coherence techniques
Essay B used first personal
pronouns throughout the report. You can use first person in a short report,
however the use of the first person tense throughout the report made it overall,
very informal.
Essay B used many effective writing styles by using a variety of coherence
techniques and using transition words to link the sentences.
Overall, both Essays were good
however I believe that Essay A ‘Beyond the Gloss: The Challenge of Flight
Attendant Rosters’ was the better Report in this case. The report was well
structured, easy to read, firm tense throughout and used the correct form of
referencing. As Essay B was quite informal, when compared to Essay A, it didn't stand out as a formal structured report.
No comments:
Post a Comment